Caribbean Sauces to Up Your Chef Game

If you’re looking for irresistible Caribbean sauces to elevate your next meal and chef game, these are the ones to try.

Caribbean Sauces

Step up your game with these spicy Caribbean sauces that are sure to satisfy your craving for sensational flavors.

It doesn't matter if you're making fall-off-the-bone jerk chicken, a simple sandwich, or just craving some flavorful heat. There's a Caribbean sauce out there perfect for taking your meal from good to “Jah know! That’s the best thing I have ever eaten!” 

As Caribbean people, we know that a sauce is anything from curry gravy to tamarind chutney and from pepper and garlic sauces to dips and vinaigrettes. Once it’s a complementing flavor adding some oomph to our meal, it’s a sauce! 

Tasty island sauces come in all different flavors, textures, and heat levels to give you an irresistible ally to top or add to your favorite meat and vegetable dishes, sandwiches, snacks, or even desserts. 

If you’re looking to up your Caribbean sauce game, get your controller ready to select your favorites!

Sweet and Sour Caribbean Sauces

Sweet and Sour

Who doesn’t love a good sweet-and-sour flavor combo? This may be one of the most iconic Caribbean pairings, with sauce makers across the region elegantly jarring up tasty blends daily. 

The most popular among the bunch are any sauces with tamarind - the Caribbean kryptonite. From tamarind-infused chocolate steak sauces to chutneys and traditional Trini sauces ready for doubles and pholourie, tamarind sauces hit the sweet and sour note every time!

Other delicious sauces include pineapple sweet and sour and rum barbecue sauces from Jamaican artisan sauce makers. If you’re looking for that quintessential umami flavor, then these sweet and sour fusions are just what you need. 

But if you’re looking for a bolder flavor, check out fiery Caribbean sauces.

Hot and Spicy Caribbean Sauces

Hot and Spicy

We believe it was the great composer Sean Paul Henriques who once said, “Down in Jamaica, we give it to you hot like a sauna.” Maybe he wasn’t referring to tasty hot sauces, but he was right about the heat! 

In both Jamaica and Trinidad, hot sauces are common on home and restaurant tables alike.

Of course, the chief ingredient among the regiment of spices is, more often than not, scotch bonnet or scorpion peppers. When combined with other ingredients, these tiny berries bring a flavorful heat to sauces like Rum-Flavored Hot Sauces, Honey-Ginger Pepper Sauces, Tamarind Hot Sauces, and of course, Jerk Sauces.

Step up your game with these spicy Caribbean sauces that are sure to satisfy your craving for sensational flavors.

Grace Jerk Seasoning

 For something on the sweeter side, we suggest trying a fruity sauce, and that’s what’s next on our list.

Fresh Fruit Caribbean Sauces

Fresh Fruit

When you combine juicy pineapples, freshly-picked mangoes, luscious limes, or perfect papayas with other tasty ingredients, you get decadent Caribbean sauces that will awaken all your senses. 

Your favorite barbecue grill chicken recipe isn’t complete without a delicious pineapple pepper sauce to add some zing or a tasty papaya-flavored scotch bonnet sauce! Or how about adding tangy mango BBQ sauce to your next roasted pork for some spicy sweetness?

Fusion fruit sauces are also perfect for pairing with various meats or hearty veggies like guava-mango or papaya-passion fruit sauces. But we can’t forget every sandwich and taco’s favorite partner, avocado pepper sauce.

While these fruity dips, marinades, gravies, and condiments are fantastic for adding sweetness, you can also try garlic-based Caribbean sauces for a more complex flavor combo.

Garlic Sauce

Garlic Sauce

As pungent as garlic can be when masterfully blended with other ingredients, it has an encapsulating flavor that is as complex as it is delicious.

Besides its many health benefits like boosting immunity, managing blood pressure, and acting as an antibiotic, garlic is also an excellent base for savory Caribbean sauces.

Your next set of wings deserves a toss in a tasty garlic lemon butter sauce or a spicy sweet garlic sauce crafted with the finest ingredients. You can even top your roasted eggplant or cauliflower with plant-based garlic pepper sauces if you're vegan.

Other traditional garlic sauces still rule the pantry, while innovative combinations like white wine and garlic or garlic honey bring fantastic flavor to your favorite foods.


Other herbs and spices also make for excellent sauces you’ll want to add to everything!

Caribbean Herbs and Spices

Herbs and Spices

Fram-grown herbs and spices are often included in sauces to help balance the flavors, but when they’re made the star of the show, they really shine!

Trinidad’s chadon beni often takes center stage in Caribbean sauces. Known in other cultures as culantro, it’s an herb used extensively in Trini cuisine. You can try this unique herb in hot sauces and peppery dips that are great for complementing traditional street foods, lunch dishes, or snacks.

Want an even fancier sauce? Try elevated options, like Caribbean basil pesto, mango basil vinaigrette, or Charred Scallion Scotch Bonnet Sauce to top your steaks or pizzas!

But what is a sauce list without the traditional ketchup and mustard? These two classic condiments are way more than just toppings for hot dogs.

Caribbean Ketchup and Mustard

Ketchup and Mustard

Nothing beats the nostalgic flavor of juicy hot dogs or burgers fresh off the grill topped with tangy ketchup and mustard. But in the Caribbean, we know we do everything a little more special!

For example, you can add sweet and tangy vibes to your sandwiches with pumpkin ketchup made from the freshest ingredients. Or, if you’re daring enough, you can add a few drops of spicy mustard to your chicken nuggets or a dash of honey mustard pepper sauce to your wings. You’ll surely be licking your fingers after these sauces enter the game!

Trust us. If you’re looking for irresistible Caribbean sauces to elevate your next meal or top your favorite dishes, these are the ones to try. We know so many more are out there, but from this list alone, you can choose your player and win the ultimate prize - the best food you’ll ever eat!

Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Featured product

Top Seller
Jamaican Snack Bundle - Caribshopper
Jamaican Snack Bundle
Sale price $89.75 CAD Regular price $107.90 CAD